Detective anime have earned a special place in the medium, especially after Death Note proved how mere dialogue and monologue could build tension and intrigue. Not many shows since have matched that level of writing or intensity. Unfortunately, the two new entries this season fall quite short.
Detective Anime Basics
Unlike most anime, detective stories focus on intellect over action. A well-written detective anime doesn’t just entertain—it challenges the viewer. The best mysteries are grounded, personal, and structured like a high-stakes chess match between protagonist and antagonist. A good villain presents such a formidable challenge that the hero must use deductive reasoning to unravel the truth, often under tight deadlines, urgent stakes, or personal risk.
The real beauty of this genre is how it makes us, the audience, think alongside the protagonist. When a solution is finally revealed, we either feel rewarded for having guessed it—or stunned that the clues were in plain sight all along.
That’s why it’s frustrating when the mystery is solved through random revelations or forced exposition. If the answer comes from nowhere, or if the show drags on long after the mystery’s already obvious, it feels dull. Worse, when the protagonist doesn’t actually work to solve the case and instead stumbles into the answer, it takes away all sense of payoff.
While elements like action or comedy can enhance a mystery anime, they should never overshadow the core mystery itself.
Few shows balance this perfectly. Death Note is the obvious standard. Monster and Pluto are masterful. Gosick and Erased are also solid examples. These anime showcase protagonists being pushed to the edge to match wits with a formidable foe—just as it should be.
The Dinner Table Detective and The Mononoke Lecture Logs of Chuzenji-sensei
The two detective anime currently airing—The Dinner Table Detective and The Mononoke Lecture Logs of Chuzenji-sensei—are adaptations of a novel and a manga, respectively. They’re animated by Studio Madhouse and 100studio.
Both are lighthearted, episodic mysteries with a mentor-student dynamic. Think of something akin to the Professor Layton games: the duo stumbles across mysteries during their daily lives and solves them. Unfortunately, while the characters are charming, the mystery aspect feels underwhelming.
Each episode sets up an intriguing mystery, the student investigates, and then the master swoops in with the solution in a dramatic reveal. The problem? The solution often comes out of nowhere. Important elements are introduced at the last minute, making you wonder: where did this new information come from? How did they make that leap in logic? How does any of it actually connect?
Instead of building a puzzle where the pieces naturally fall into place, the show feels like it’s making up the solution as it goes. There’s little satisfaction in watching the mystery unfold because the payoff doesn’t feel earned. The protagonist hardly gets a chance to shine; the mentor overshadows everything. Add to that some unnecessary filler and annoying side characters, and it becomes hard to stay engaged.
Afterthought
Maybe I’m being too harsh. These shows are still enjoyable if you’re looking for light mysteries without too much mental strain. The Dinner Table Detective and The Mononoke Lecture Logs of Chuzenji-sensei feel similar to Ron Kamonohashi’s Forbidden Deductions, which at least has some solid character moments. But I wish the mystery elements were handled more seriously—more like what we’re seeing in Kowloon Generic Romance, also airing this season.
There’s another detective anime airing this season as well: Your Forma, but lost interest in that too quickly to give an in-depth reviews and thoughts on it. It’s taking a different approach than these two. Lazarus is another concurrent show that can be regarded as detective/mystery, but will make a separate post on it soon.
Thank you for reading ♡. More Anime Reviews here if you are interested. Here’re our pricks for spring 2025 anime. Join with the community on our Discord server & Telegram chat. Check out our YouTube channel for extra content. Take care.
